Nov
19
2008
Eating Liberally: melamine again
Kat’s question for me is “Shouldn’t the FDA keep melamine out of our domestic food chain?” Well yes. It should. And thanks to Sokie Lee for forwarding the Mao poster from her “say no to made in China” campaign. Still, I don’t think we should be too xenophobic about China. After all, its food safety system is about where ours was before we got food and drug laws in 1906. It’s just a lot bigger and more complicated so it has even more work to do to keep its – and our – food safe. And here’s Sokie’s poster in miniature:
Leave a comment
Next public appearance
Mar
18
2010
Ithaca, NY: Cornell
Cornell Institute of Public Affairs, colloquium series, 4:30 p.m. 233 Plant Sciences on “The food revolution: implications for public policy.” Free and open to the public.
Search
Related posts
Topics for this post
All Topics
(ACSH) American Council on Science and Health
5 a Day
AAFP (American Academy of Family Physicians)
Acrylamide
Activity
Addiction
Additives
Advocacy
Aging
Agriculture
AHA (American Heart Association)
Alcohol
Alice Waters
Allergies
American Academy of Pediatrics
American Dietetic Association
American Heart Association
Animals
Antibiotics
antioxidant
Antioxidants
ASN (American Society of Nutrition)
Asthma
Açaí
Beef
Bill Marler
Biofuel
Bisphenol A
blogs
Books
Bottled water
Breakfast
Breast feeding
Brian Wansink
Bribery
Burger King
Caffeine
CAFOs
calcium
calore labeling
Calorie labels
Calories
Canada
Cancer
Candy
Cargill
CCF (Center for Consumer Freedom)
CDC (Centers for Disease Control)
Cereals
Charlie Rose
Cheerios
Cheese
Chickens
China
Chinese infant formula
Chocolate
Cholesterol
Climate change
Cloned animals
Coca Cola
Colbert
consolidation
Cookie dough
Cooking measurements
COOL (Country of Origin Labeling)
Corn
Corn sweeteners
corrections
Costs
CSPI
CSPI (Center for Science in the Public Interest)
Dairy
denmark
Diabetes
diet
Diet and energy drinks
dietary advice
Dietary guidelines
diet drugs
Diets
Diet sodas
Disney
E. coli
EatingLiberally
Eat less & move more
EFSA (European Food Safety Authority)
eggs
energy drinks
Eric Schlosser
Ethanol
Events
Excerpt
F&V
FAQ
farmers markets
Farm po
Farm policy
farms
Fast food
Fats and oils
FDA
feed efficiency
Fiber
films
Fish
Flaxseed
Food
Food and Water Watch
Food art
Food assistance
Food availability
Food choice
Food colors
Food Composition
Food crisis
Food culture
Food deserts
Food Inc
Food industry
Food industry regulation
Food magazines
Food marketing
Food miles
Food movement
Food policy
Food quality
Food safety
Food security
Food stamps
Food studies
food supply
Food systems
food trade
food waste
Framingham Heart Study
Fruits & vegetables
FTC (Federal Trade Commission)
Functional foods
GAO
Gardens
Gary Taubes
General Mills
Gluten
GM (Genetically Modified)
GMA (Grocery Manufacturers Association)
Grassfed
Green food
HACCP
Hannaford
Health aura
Health claims
health statistics
Heart disease
HFCS (High Fructose Corn Syrup)
HHS (Department of Health and Human Services)
Hormones
Hugo drinks
hyperactivity
Inc.
India
Infant formula
Interviews
IOM (Institute of Medicine)
iraq
irradiation
Japan
Job Ads
Joy of Cooking
Juice drinks
juices
Junk food
Kellogg
Kelly Brownell
Kids' diets
King Corn
Korea
Kraft
krill
Labels
Lawsuits
Legislation
lobbies
Local food
Lévi-Strauss
Mad cow
malnutrition
Manure
maps
Margarines
Marketing to kids
Mark Hegsted
Mars
McDonalds
meal frequency
Meat
Meat safety
media
Melamine
Mercury
Michael Pollan
Michael Taylor
military
Milk
Monsanto
move more
Movies
MSG
Nanotechnology
Natural
neighborhoods
Nestlé
New York City
New Zealand
Niman
Nutrition education
Nutritionism
Obama
Obesity
Obesity in kids
obesity policy
Omega 3 Fats
Organic fish
Organics
Organic standards
orthorexia
Oysters
partnerships
Patents
Peanut butter
PepsiCo
personal responsibility
pesticides
Peter Jennings
Pet food
Phil Lempert
Photos
Pistachios
pizza
Pork
Portion sizes
potatoes
pregnancy
Price fixing
Price of food
prices
Probiotics
Pyramid
Quotes from What to Eat
recipes
Red Bull
Restaurants
Revolving door
Rosa DeLauro
RWJ Foundation
Salt
San Francisco Chronicle
School food
Scoring systems
shrek
Single food agency
Slow Food
Smart Choices
Social responsibility
Soft drinks
soy
spinach
splenda
Sponsorship
starvation
Stevia
sticky
Sugar
Supermarkets
Supplements
Supreme court
Surveys
sushi
sweeteners
Swine flu
Taste
Taxes
techno foods
Television
Thomas Friedan
Tobacco
Tomatoes
toxins
Trans fat
Tufts
Twitter
Tyson foods
USDA
vegetables
Vegetarian and vegan
Vending machines
Videos
Vitamins
vitamin water
Wall street
Wal Mart
water
WHO
Whole Foods
Whole Grains
WIC
World hunger
Yearly Kos
Yogurt

Comments
Hillary Clinton introduced legislation to require country of origin labels on dairy products. Given the fact that milk products have become a bit of a commodity, it would likely be difficult to implement, but I support the bill.
I think food labeling is the great equalizer — whether it’s calories on menu boards, genetically engineered disclsoures or FDA mandates for front of box nutrition information. People vote with their wallets and if a product scares people, they will not buy it. That is probably as powerful as any law can be.
I don’t support the villainization of China though. I think it’s a bit much.
Rick Tannenbaum
http://www.foodrecalls.blogspot.com
I think that if China’s food safety is a 100 years behind that it is not ready for prime time. I have no problem villainizing China. If they want to do business with the US then they need to step up to the plate safety wise.
Who are you willing to sacrifice while we wait for China to catch up: your children? your ailing parents? your pets?
Sorry I just don’t agree with this don’t be hard on China. But we also need better food inspection for imports.
The New York Times just published an enlightening article about Melamine issues in the USA. The bottom line is: as long as the public thinks that China is the only culprit, nobody will notice the problems in our own food industry. Here’s the article:
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/17/opinion/17mcwilliams.html?scp=2&sq=melamine%20&st=cse
Maria is right. China is not the only culprit when it comes to food safety. Other countries are guilty as well.
What about the Chilean salmon issue? Last year, the salmon anemia virus made a small wave of headlines, which caused MILLIONS of salmon to die. No one noticed. Prices did not go up. There was no salmon shortage; yet 1200 salmon workers from Marine Harvest, Costco’s vendor, were laid off.
How could that be? Costco must had sold the infected salmon to consumers.
The melamine problem: when Menu pet foods
were recalled in March 2007, I estimate over 350,000 cats and dogs were sickened with renal failure. I estimate this by the number of patients I saw in one week, as a part time veterinarian (3), multiplied by the number of veterinarians in the US. I keep seeing 4500 as the victims of this melamine/cyanuric acid intentional adulteration of our pets foods and believe it to be grossly inaccurate. In fact “confirmed cases” as measured by laboratory testing is much lower than 4500. The cost of confirming the diagnosis has always been a stumbling block for our veterinary clients, as they are limited by their own financial constraints. More would have been confirmed had the testing been free to clients/vets. And the actual number of pets that were sickened was many times higher.
Two weeks ago I saw a cat in my hospital. She had been ill from kidney failure she was stricken with in March of 2007. She was cradled in her owners arms, nearly lifeless, jaws limp, and semi conscious, The owners crying pitifully as they requested humane euthanasia. Their cat had only been given more time because the owners had invested thousands of dollars in specialist care. She had been diagnosed with cyanuric acid crystals in her kidneys very early on. It was very difficult for me to euthanize her, but I put on my professional face and did my duty. So sad.
I remember being so angry when the pet food recall happened that I decided to take action in the only way I thought I could make a difference. I wrote a home made pet food cookbook HOW TO COOK FOR YOUR PET, so pet owners could make safe foods for their pets. I included two pages of foods and food ingredients that I call the No No List that counsel owners away from foods people commonly consume that when fed to dogs and cats are toxic, indigestible, or provoke illnesses. I have self published the cookbook a year ago and have sold many copies. Now a publisher will be publishing my second edition in February 2009. I did not do this for profit, I did it to help the animals that I have been caring for as a veterinarian for 30 years. Early in my career I noticed illnesses pets had, that were cured by better quality, more digestible foods. I have studied pet nutrition extensively too.
The reason I am writing you this evening is because I saw your interview on VIN today, and I was so moved by your caring attitude towards pets, as witnessed by your books esp. …the chihuahua in the coal mine. It is a well known fact that pets and the people they live with often have very similar illnesses, and often the pet will get it first (diabetes, cancer, allergies, etc.). I will be purchasing the book shortly to read.
Just as the canary warned coal miners of dangerous gas fumes in the mine (by dieing), we should take seriously the warning we have been given by thousands of pets who died. Let us not ignore this warning, or they have died in vain.
I hope that you will continue to help people understand the importance of wholesome foods both for people and for pets, and push our government to improve the FDA’s functions to protect both people and pets.
Sincerely, Dr Amy Cousino, Sebastian, FL