by Marion Nestle
Jan 19 2009

CSPI sues Coke over Vitamin Water claims

Center for Science in the Public Interest has filed a class-action lawsuit against Coca-Cola, the parent company of Glaceau Vitamin Water.   Vitamin Water, says CSPI, makes sugary drinks that promote obesity but positions these products as healthful because they contain added vitamins and herbs.  Does this make them healthier?  No, but it certainly makes them sell better.

Comments

We recently put up an article on the evils of Vitamin Water at Fork & Bottle:

http://www.forkandbottle.com/rants/food/vitamin_charged_kids_and_crystalline_fructose.htm

I made it to the Fancy Foods Show here in San Francisco yesterday where I saw numerous displays of various waters labeled “healthy” (“No sugar!”) and flavored with everything from cucumbers to various herbs and touted for their alleged environmental responsibility.

What I didn’t see, in any example, was how any of these bottled waters were better than – oh, I don’t know – a plain old glass of water.

I have a question in regard to this statement from the article: “Coke came under fire in December by the FDA, which said claims Diet Coke Plus includes a variety of vitamins and minerals violate U.S. policy against marketing soda and other snack foods as more nutritious.”

When a soda or other snack food has had vitamins and minerals added to it, isn’t it actually more nutritious (assuming actual absorption of the stuff)? Why does such a law exist except to babysit the confused populous? Drinking Diet Coke Plus has got to be at least a little better than drinking its alternative. I say let them market their VitaminWater less as a “health food” and more as a “healthier alternative food”.

[...] Marion Nestle [...]

  • Daniel Ithaca, NY
  • January 23, 2009
  • 3:48 am

In response to I say let them market their VitaminWater less as a “health food” and more as a “healthier alternative food”.

It is trickey for a company to use “2.5 servings” label for their bottle, who really divides a 20oz (.6L) into 2.5 servings?
Maybe the Nutrition Facts should have the number of servings per container–if the container is standarly consumed in ‘one serving’.

13g of sugar becomes 33g of sugar per common. The World Health Organization recommends consuming 50g or less per day of added sugars. 66% of sugar in water. With a spinkling of vitamins. This doesn’t sound much different than a sugary soda.
Why not just have some 100% juice, a real food? That’s what I use for a sports drink!

Leave a comment