Jan
31
2009
San Francisco Chronicle: what’s up with vitamin D?
My latest column for the San Francisco Chronicle tackles today’s vexing questions about vitamin D. How much do we need? How much is safe? How much of the fuss about it is due to marketing hype? No easy answers on this one, alas.
Leave a comment
Next public appearance
May
29
2013
New York: 92nd St Y, Tribeca
This is a conversation about 101 Classic Cookbooks, 501 Classic Recipes (Rizzoli Books, 2013), with Clark Wolf, Marvin Taylor (curator NYU Fales Library), Rose Levy Beranbaum (author, The Cake Bible), and Madhur Jaffrey (actor and author). 7:30 p.m. 92ndY Tribeca, 200 Hudson St, Price $15, RSVP: here

Search
Related posts
Topics for this post
All Topics
5-a-Day
AAFP(American Academy of Family Physicians)
AAP(American Academy of Pediatrics)
Acrylamide
ACSH(American Council on Science and Health)
Activity
ADA(American Dietetic Association)
Addiction
Additives
Advocacy
Agave
Aging
Agriculture
AHA(American Heart Association)
Alcohol
Alice-Waters
Allergies
Amercan Beverage Association
American-Diabetes-Association
Animals
Antibiotics
Antioxidants
Arsenic
Artificial-sweeteners
ASN(American Society of Nutrition)
Asthma
Açaí
Beef
Bees
Bill-Marler
Biofuel
Blogs
Books
Bottled-water
BPA
BPA(Bisphenol-A)
Bread
Breakfast
Breast-feeding
Brian-Wansink
Bribery
Burger-King
Caffeine
CAFOs(Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations)
calcium
Calorie-labeling
Calories
Campbell
Canada
Cancer
Candy
Cantaloupe
Carcinogens
Cargill
CCF(Center for Consumer Freedom)
CDC(Centers for Disease Control)
CDC(Centers for Disease Control)
Cereals
Charlie-Rose
Checkoff
Cheerios
Cheese
Chicken
Chickens
China
Chinese-infant-formula
Chocolate
Cholesterol
Climate change
Cloned-animals
Coca-Cola
Coffee
Colbert
Comments
Comments-Monitoring-Policy
Comments-Policy-Monitoring
ConAgra
Conflicts-of-interest
Consolidation
Consumer Reports
Cookie-dough
Cooking
Cooking-measurements
COOL(Country of Origin Labeling)
Corn
CSPI
CSPI(Center for Science in the Public Interest)
CSR(Corporate Social Responsibility)
Dairy
Del Monte
Denmark
Dental-disease
Diabetes
Diet-and-dieting
Diet-and-energy-drinks
Diet-drugs
Dietary-Guidelines
Diets
Disney
E.coli
Eat-less-and-move-more
Eating Liberally
EFSA
EFSA(European Food Safety Authority)
Eggs
Energy drinks
EPA
Eric-Schlosser
Ethanol
Ethics
Events
Excerpt
FAO
FAQ
Farm-bill
Farm-policy
Farm-workers
farmers markets
Farms
Fast food
Fats-and-oils
FDA
feed efficiency
Fiber
films
First Amendment
Fish
Flaxseed
FMI(Food Marketing Institute)
Food
Food-access
Food-and-Water-Watch
Food-art
Food-assistance
Food-availability
Food-choice
Food-colors
Food-composition
Food-crisis
Food-culture
Food-deserts
Food-guide
Food-history
Food-Inc
Food-industry
Food-industry-regulation
Food-magazines
Food-marketing
Food-miles
Food-movement
Food-policy
Food-quality
Food-safety
Food-security
Food-stamps
Food-studies
Food-supply
Food-systems
Food-trade
Food-waste
Food aid
FOP(Front-of-Package)Labels
Fortification
Framingham-Heart-Study
Fruits-and-vegetables
FTC (Federal Trade Commission)
Functional-foods
Futures-markets
GAO
GAO(Government Accountability Office)
Gardens
Gary-Taubes
General-Mills
Gluten
GM(Genetically Modified)
GMA(Grocery Manufacturers Association)
Grassfed
Green-food
HACCP(Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Point)
Hannaford
Health-aura
Health-claims
Health-statistics
Heart-disease
HFCS (High Fructose Corn Syrup)
HHS(Department of Health and Human Services)
Hormones
Horsemeat
Hugo drinks
Hunger
Hydroponics
hyperactivity
IASO
India
Infant-formula
International
Interviews
IOM (Institute of Medicine)
iraq
Irradiation
IWG(Interagency Working Group)
Jamie-Oliver
Japan
Job-Ads
Joy-of-Cooking
Juice-drinks
juices
Junk food
Kellogg
Kelly-Brownell
KFC
Kids' diets
King-Corn
Korea
Kosher
Kraft
krill
Label-scoring-systems
Labels
Lawsuits
Legislation
Let's Ask Marion
Let's Move!
Letters-From-Food-Companies
Listeria
Lobbies
Local-food
Lévi-Strauss
Mad-cow-disease
Malnutrition
Manure
maps
Margarines
Marketing to kids
Mark Hegsted
Mars
McDonald's
meal frequency
Meat
Meat safety
Meat substitutes
media
Melamine
Mercury
Michael-Pollan
Michael-Taylor
military
Milk
Monsanto
Movies
MSG
Museum exhibits
MyPlate
Nanotechnology
Natural
neighborhoods
Nestlé
New-York-City
New-Zealand
Niman
Nutrient-availability
Nutrition-education
Nutrition-standards
Nutritionism
Nuts
Obama
Obesity
Obesity-in-kids
Obesity-policy
Occupy
Omega-3-fats
Organic
Organic-fish
Organic-standards
Organics
orthorexia
Oxfam
Oysters
Pakistan
Partnerships
Passover
Patents
Paula Deen
Paul Ryan
Peanut-butter
Peanuts
PepsiCo
Personal-responsibility
Pesticides
Peter Jennings
Pet food
Phil Lempert
Photos
Pink-slime
Pistachios
pizza
Pork
Portion sizes
Potatoes
pregnancy
Pric
Price-fixing
Price-of-food
Probiotics
Processing
Protein
Public-health
Pyramid
Quotes from What to Eat
Radioactivity
Raw-foods
Raw-milk
rBGH
recipes
Red-Bull
Regulation
Research
Restaurants
Revolving-door
Right-to-food
Rosa DeLauro
RWJ Foundation
S.510
Salmonella
Salt
San-Francisco-Chronicle
scho
School-food
Seeds
shrek
Single-food-agency
Slow Food
Smart Choices
Snack foods
Socioeconomic-factors
Soft drinks
soy
Spinach
Splenda
Sponsored-research
Sprouts
Starvation
Stevia
sticky
Sugars
Sugars
Supermarkets
Supplements
Supreme court
Surveys
sushi
Sweeteners
Swine flu
Taste
Taxes
Techno-foods
Television
Thomas Friedan
Tim Lang
Tobacco
Tomatoes
Toxins
Trans-fat
Tufts
Twitter
Tyson-foods
United Nations
Urban-farming
USDA
Vegetables
Vegetarian-and-vegan
Vending-machines
Videos
Vitamin-water
Vitamin D
Vitamins
Wall-Street
Walmart
Washington-Square-News
Water
WHO(World Health Organization)
Whole Foods
Whole grains
Why-Calories-Count
WIC
World hunger
Yearly Kos
Yogurt

Comments
I agree that our vitamin D sources should be as natural as possible. However, I am not yet comfortable with the recommendation I often hear to apply sunscreen after 15 minutes in the sun. Since I was a child, I heard that in order for sunscreen to be fully effective, it should be applied 1/2 hour before going out in the sun (The skin cancer foundation also states this the protocol for applying sunscreen: http://www.skincancer.org/the-scfs-guide-to-sunscreens.html). Given this advice goes back at least 20 years, I wonder if that has ever been challenged or debunked. Are there any studies that show a significant protective effect with it being applied after going out in the sun? The efficacy vs. effectiveness debate comes to mind.
One of the leading researchers into the mechanisms of vitamin D, Michael Hollick MD PhD, was asked to leave the Dermatology department at Boston University (he was co-appointed to Dermatology and Internal Medicine) after making the same exact suggestion that you made, i.e. to spend 15 minutes per day in full sun. A controversial topic, to say the least.
But, even since you published your article, yet another link seems to have been solidified, this time between vitamin D and MS. I hope that the Institute of Medicine panel will have some good recommendations; in the meantime myself and many other physicians are taking 400 IU supplements, with a goal of 600-800 IU total per day.
yeah its quite good render more information about it.
———————————–
sanjeppu
http://www.naturallynovascotia.com
A Canadian company, Naturally Nova Scotia, makes supplements from foods instead of synthetics. The have vitamin C from fruit, herbal tinctures, green drinks, vitamin D3, and others.
Vitamin D is not a vitamin. It was incorrectly identified as a vitamin when it was discovered. The active metabolite, 1,25 dihydroxy vitamin D, activates the Vitamin D Receptor (VDR) in our cells which is key to the functioning of the immune system. All the “vitamin” D we need is produced and controlled by the body. To add it to foods beyond any natural level is to upset what the body is trying to do naturally.
Go to Bacteriality.com for more complete information. The vitamin D lobby is doing the public a great disservice in pushing vitamin D into our food supply.
Doctors who prescribe huge levels of D do so blindly. They measure the level of 25 hydroxy vitamin D, the inactive metabolite, in the blood and conclude it is low. If they would take the time to measure the level of the active metabolite, 1,25 dihydroxy vitamin D, they would see the level is actually high (in most people) thanks to our friends in the food supplement business.
I believe that many of today’s alarmingly high levels of autoimmune diseases are directly linked to the food industry’s belief that vitamin D is a good thing to add to food. We can’t escape it, and it is doing us grave damage!
Phil Schoner
1,25 dihydroxy vitamin D,
Is there a simple test for the above substance?