The 2010 Dietary Guidelines: Enjoy your food, but eat less!
The 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans were just released. Here are the take-home messages:
Balancing Calories
• Enjoy your food, but eat less.
• Avoid oversized portions.
Foods to Increase
• Make half your plate fruits and vegetables.
• Switch to fat-free or low-fat (1%) milk.
Foods to Reduce
• Compare sodium in foods like soup, bread, and frozen meals—and choose the foods with lower numbers.
• Drink water instead of sugary drinks.
I’m in shock. I never would have believed they could pull this off. The new guidelines recognize that obesity is the number one public health nutrition problem in America and actually give good advice about what to do about it: eat less and eat better. For the first time, the guidelines make it clear that eating less is as priority.
My two quibbles:
Quibble #1: They still talk about foods (fruits, vegetables, seafood, beans, nuts) when they say “eat more.” But they switch to nutrient euphemisms (sodium, solid fats and added sugars) when they mean “eat less.”
They say, for example: “limit the consumption of foods that contain refined grains, especially refined grain foods that contain solid fats, added sugars, and sodium.”
This requires translation: eat less meat, cake, cookies, sodas, juice drinks, and salty snacks.
That’s politics, for you.
Let’s give them credit for “drink water instead of sugary drinks.” That comes close. But I listened in on the press conference and conference call and several people pushed federal officials about why they didn’t come out and say “eat less meat.” The answers waffled.
Quibble #2: This is all about personal responsibility. What about the “toxic” food environment? Shouldn’t these guidelines be directed at the food and restaurant industries? The Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee made a big point of that. Apparently, that’s in the full dietary guidelines report but I’ve only seen the executive summary.
For background, see my previous posts, one on the politics of this report, and one on the science of the dietary guidelines.
Overall, the new guidelines aren’t perfect but they are a great improvement.
Next: let’s see what they do to improve the implementation guide—the pyramid or its equivalent. This, they say will come out in a few months. Stay tuned.
Leave a comment
Follow Marion
Next public appearance
New York: 92nd St Y, Tribeca
This is a conversation about 101 Classic Cookbooks, 501 Classic Recipes (Rizzoli Books, 2013), with Clark Wolf, Marvin Taylor (curator NYU Fales Library), Rose Levy Beranbaum (author, The Cake Bible), and Madhur Jaffrey (actor and author). 7:30 p.m. 92ndY Tribeca, 200 Hudson St, Price $15, RSVP: here
Comments
[...] USDA released a new set of dietary guidelines this week and the updated guidelines were enough to put nutritionist Marion Nestle in [...]
[...] One of the most (food) news-making events this week was the release of the 2010 Dietary Guidelines. I’m as amazed as Marion Nestle is that they actually promote eating less of certain foods. Read Marion’s full article here. [...]
[...] The USDA released new dietary guidelines this week. I think they’re a great step in the right direction, but just a step. Here’s Marion Nestle’s take. [...]
[...] One of the most (food) news-making events this week was the release of the 2010 Dietary Guidelines. I’m as amazed as Marion Nestle is that they actually promote eating less of certain foods. Read Marion’s full article here. [...]
[...] The 2010 Dietary Guidelines: Enjoy Your Food, but Eat Less! (Food Politics) [...]
“Eat less meat” has lead to political troubles before, when the giant, powerful meat industry objected to the government promoting this message (that, and the USDA is charged with promoting the sales and consumption of meat and other ag products as you know).
[...] USDA released a new set of dietary guidelines this week and the updated guidelines were enough to put nutritionist Marion Nestle in “shock”: I never would have believed they could pull this off. The new guidelines [...]
[...] USDA released a new set of dietary guidelines this week and the updated guidelines were enough to put nutritionist Marion Nestle in “shock”: I never would have believed they could pull this off. The new guidelines [...]
[...] interesting commentary on the new Guidelines, check out Marion Nestle’s blog, the New York Times article, and/or the Huffington [...]
[...] USDA released a new set of dietary guidelines this week and the updated guidelines were enough to put nutritionist Marion Nestle in [...]
[...] Politics, Dr. Marion Nestle on The Atlantic. You can also read her first article on the subject, on her blog, where she discusses a few problems she has with them. Seriously, you can stop right there. Its the [...]
So there might be a possibility that the food pyramid will actually change shape? I mean they have put a lot of money implementing MyPyramid as a pyramidal representation. It will be interesting to see what they actaully will come up with.
[...] was also revealing that this time around, veteran food politics expert Marion Nestle was “in shock” at such obvious DGA statements as, “avoid oversized [...]
[...] did get a little better this time around. Veteran food politics maven Marion Nestle declared herself “in shock” at such obvious DGA statements as, “avoid oversized [...]
[...] ravitsemussuosituksia on puitu monissa medioissa. Professori Marion Nestle ihmettelee suositussa blogissaan, miksi viitataan ruokaan (hedelmät, kasvikset, kalat, pähkinät) kun puhutaan, mitä pitäisi [...]
[...] in shock," writes Marion Nestle, an author and New York University professor who has followed these proceedings and written about [...]
[...] eat less meat or fewer Three Musketeers bars). We’ve tweeted about other food policy writers like Marion Nestle who have made this point and it is an important one. Until the USDA resolves this multiple [...]
[...] obesity epidemic. “I’m in shock,” said author and New York University professor Marion Nestle. She continued: The new guidelines recognize that obesity is the number one public health nutrition [...]
[...] did get a little better this time around. Veteran food politics maven Marion Nestle declared herself “in shock” at such obvious DGA statements as, “avoid oversized [...]
[...] Studies, and Public Health at New York University, summed up her shock (in a good way) on her blogMonday:“I never would have believed they could pull this off. The new guidelines recognize [...]
[...] how-to messages to beam healthy eating that were expelled with a 2010 Dietary Guidelines, and that I enthusiastically posted when a Guidelines were expelled (I was unhappy that they weren’t indeed partial of a [...]
[...] pointed out on her blog, Food Politics, that several health organizations, including the American Diabetes Association, American Institute [...]
[...] su blog Food Politics dijo que varias organizaciones de salud, incluyendo la Asociación Americana de Diabetes, el [...]
[...] forked out on her blog, Food Politics, that several health organizations, including a American Diabetes Association, American Institute [...]
[...] pointed out on her blog, Food Politics, that several health organizations, including the American Diabetes Association, American Institute [...]
[...] pointed out on her blog, Food Politics, that several health organizations, including the American Diabetes Association, American Institute [...]
[...] pointed out on her blog, Food Politics, that several health organizations, including the American Diabetes Association, American Institute [...]
[...] pointed out on her blog, Food Politics, that several health organizations, including the American Diabetes Association, American Institute [...]
[...] editor, I thought I’d give it a try. When the 2010 DGAs were first announced last January, like a lot of people, I was pleasantly surprised by many of the updates to the guidelines from their previous iteration [...]
[...] pointed out on her blog, Food Politics, that several health organizations, including the American Diabetes Association, American Institute [...]