by Marion Nestle
Jan 26 2011

FDA withdraws menu labeling guidance. Will work on rules instead.

The FDA announces that it is immediately withdrawing its guidance to the food industry issued in August about how companies should do menu labeling. It will start formal rulemaking instead.  Try some FDA-speak:

As stated in the draft guidance, certain provisions of section 4205 of the Affordable Care Act became requirements immediately upon enactment of the law. FDA also stated that it anticipated issuing the final guidance and enforcement policy in December 2010.FDA received many comments on the draft guidance and on a public docket which FDA opened to solicit comment.

Based, in part, on these comments, FDA now intends to complete the notice and comment rulemaking process for section 4205 before initiating enforcement activities and will not be publishing a final guidance on menu labeling at this time. FDA is required to issue proposed regulations to carry out provisions of section 4205 no later than March 23, 2011. FDA intends to meet this statutory deadline.

FDA believes that the expeditious completion of the rulemaking process for section 4205 will minimize uncertainty and confusion among all interested parties. This approach to implementing section 4205 will most rapidly lead to full and consistent availability of the newly required nutrition information for consumers.

I’m not sure how to translate this.  I think it means that companies currently posting calories should continue to do so.

The FDA still needs time to work out some of the sticky details—calorie ranges like the ones used by Chipotle, for example.  It intends to meet the legislated deadline for issuing rules a year from now.  States and local communities currently requiring calorie labeling should continue to do so but should off on enforcement until then. 

Let’s not hurry these things.

Unsurprisingly, the restaurant industry “supports this approach.”  As The Packer put it, “Don’t sweat menu labeling just yet. Thise just in from the FDA…”

Patience is a virtue.  This willl happen.   Eventually.

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention Food Politics » FDA withdraws menu labeling guidance. Will work on rules instead. -- Topsy.com()

  • Ferrer

    I believe that the FDA is an enter to know products regularly. Mentions Findrxonline this organization is responsible for ensuring the rights of millions of people and controlled prescription drugs and food.

  • Anthro

    Oh dear, I’m going to be dead before anything meaningful happens!
    —-
    “…certain provisions of section 4205 of the Affordable Care Act became requirements immediately upon enactment of the law.”

    Can you expand on this? “Immediately” sound good! But what “requirements” are there?

  • Pingback: Food Politics: Jan. 25, 2011 « Speaker's Corner()

  • brenda

    Can you tell me what the legislated deadline for issuing rules a year from now is? What is this legislated date?